This quick tutorial shows you how to fix ssh error “sign_and_send_pubkey: signing failed: agent refused operation Permission denied (publickey)” on Linux.
If you are trying to connect to the remote server via SSH, you might encounter permission denied error. This error may happen for a number of reasons. And the fix to this issue depends upon the exact reason behind the error.
In my case, I had the public and private keys stored on my Ubuntu 16.04 desktop. After Ubuntu 18.04 release, I decided to upgrade to this newer version. I prefer a fresh install over distribution upgrades.
So, I made a backup of the main folders of my Home directory including the .ssh folder that had public and private keys on an external disk. After installing Ubuntu 18.04, I restored everything including the SSH keys.
Now when I tried to connect to the remote server using ssh, I thought it would work straightaway because I had the same public and private keys.
But it didn’t work. SSH gave me this error:
sign_and_send_pubkey: signing failed: agent refused operation
root@xxx.xxx.xxx.xx: Permission denied (publickey).If you are in a similar situation where you copied your SSH keys from another source, let me show you how to fix this SSH error.
Fixing Permission denied (publickey) error
So the problem lies with file permissions here. You see, when I copied the files, the USB was in Microsoft’s FAT file format. This file doesn’t support the UNIX/Linux file permissions.
And hence the permissions on the copied ssh keys were changed to 777.
For SSH, the file permissions are too open. It’s simply not allowed to have 777 permissions on the public or private keys. And this is why SSH refused connection here.
ls -l .ssh
-rwxrwxrwx 1 abhishek abhishek 1766 Nov 12 2017 id_rsa
-rwxrwxrwx 1 abhishek abhishek 398 Nov 12 2017 id_rsa.pub
-rwxrwxrwx 1 abhishek abhishek 4214 Sep 21 21:39 known_hostsThe private key should have read and write permissions only for the user and no other permissions for the group and others.
You should change the permission using the
chmod 600 ~/.ssh/id_rsaSimilarly, the public key shouldn’t have write and execute permissions for group and other.
chmod 644 ~/.ssh/id_rsa.pubNow that you have put the correct permissions, you can connect to ssh again. At this time, it will ask your admin password to unlock the keys. Enter your admin password and you should be good to go.
This also taught me a lesson that
As I said earlier, there can be various reasons for this error. For the issue related to open file permission, this fix should help you fix the Permission denied (publickey) error with SSH.
Let me know in the comment section if the fix worked for you or not. Also suggest your opinion on copying ssh keys on other computers.
Just me, but I always recommend using symbol rights instead of octal rights in chmod(1). That because it is adopted to real users, and you can make it do what you want. That is, only change the rights you want to change and let the others be as it was.
It is also easier to do the right thing with symbolic rights.
chmod u=rw,go= ~/.ssh/id_rsa
chmod u=rw,go=r ~/.ssh/id_rsa.pub
It is much easier for me, and then I have been using Unix since 1984 or something.
If you reinstall a machine where you have had keys generated, you should also take a backup of /etc/sshd/ so the old keys can be restored. Then you don’t need to acknowledge the new keys when you use ssh(1) later to this machine.
Notice, you have to use the same machine name for the keys to work.